Craigslist win! How we scored a great craigslist deal
You ever read those posts where someone has some kind of great something and they found it on the curb, or got it on craigslist for a couple bucks or found it at the Restore for almost pennies?
Yeah, me too–and I always think:
Why not me?
Why can’t I find a slew of cabinets for $6 like John and Sherry did?
Or a free bed and a super-cheap thrift store duvet and curtains like Kat at Maple Leaves & Sycamore Trees did?
But no more craigslist envy for me because I finally found it: My craigslist deal.
We’ve been casually looking for a couch to replace the futon in our family room. (You may have noticed it in our recent family room painting drama.)
I’d get on craigslist once a week or so and try all kinds of searches–with retro, vintage, sofa, couch. I kept telling Cane I wanted something 70s–something so dated it would be kitschy-cool.
“You know,” I said, “like a plaid or floral couch, like we’ve seen in the vintage shops on Hawthorne.”

This one is actually from a shop across the river in Vancouver, Vintage Connection. Image via Craigslist.
A few nights ago Cane was dinking around on craigslist, and he said, “Is this the kind of couch you’re looking for?”
Heck ya–and for only $100, the deal was for both a couch and a chair.
And–most important for actually getting the craigslist score–it had only been posted an hour before. I was the first one to contact the seller, so (short story really short) the couch and chair were ours.
(And I discovered the greatest craigslist tool this week–CraigsEasy. It’s been around awhile so I’m sure many of you already know about it, but it was new to me. Simply drag a button to your tool bar, and then click on it after doing your craiglist search. It will show you all the photos with the posts that came up in your search. No more clicking on every.single.link.!)
Were these guys in super-great shape? No, but I didn’t expect them to be for a hundred bucks.
We did like the long, low lines of them, though…
…and the retro fabric, which is a nice mix of green and gold floral, but not in-your-face floral.
We spent most of the next day cleaning them, and it wasn’t fun or pretty.
There was a lot of dog hair (but from a super-sweet, friendly lab we met during the transaction, which somehow made the hair more tolerable).
We bought one can of rug/upholstery cleaner, but it took 2 to get the job done. We ended up with an assortment of products.

Don’t these cans all look like they mean business? We only needed 2, so we didn’t try the Tuff Stuff.
And, we discovered that the cushions are made of what has to be the original foam, and in some places they had deteriorated and stuck to the cushion covers. We purposely didn’t take any pictures of the foam inserts because we know that if the kids saw them they would refuse to sit on this furniture. (We have yet to convert them to our thrifty ways or sense of style.)
But…it looked pretty gross. We thought about getting replacement foam–but foam for three cushions would cost $150.00! And, aside from ugliness (which you don’t see when the covers are on), the cushions were in good shape. They still have lots of spring. We think this was a high-quality piece when new.
So we brushed off all the crumbling bits and let them air out in the sun for a full day and stuffed them back into their covers.
Freshly cleaned covers, that is.
The cushion covers got to dry in the sun, too.
While vacuuming and scrubbing, I had a chance to think a bit about the whole subject of OPD (Other People’s Dirt). I used to be a huge OPD snob. Especially about old OPD.
I didn’t want stuff that others had gotten dirty, and especially didn’t want to deal with dirt that had been around for awhile. But you know what? It’s just dirt.
It washes off (usually). And someone else’s dirt isn’t any dirtier than our own.
I don’t know where this particular kind of snobbery originated in me, but I think it’s time I (and all of us) got over it.
This sofa and chair have years of good wear left in them, and all they needed was a little TLC. I’m feeling really good that they’ll be hanging out at our house (instead of at a dump) and that we didn’t drop hundreds of dollars for a new couch and chair.

Sure, it’s a little raggedy. But it’s in our family room, setting for snacks, afternoon football naps, and the occasional rousing game of Twister. No need for pristine furniture here.
We spiffed them up with some new pillows. We had one of the green/blue/gold on white pillows already (from when I was still trying to work blue into the living room), and we thought it looked great with the sofa. So, I went and picked up another one (from World Market), along with some inexpensive gold ones.
I felt OK about indulging in new pillows because the couch and chair really cost us almost nothing. We put the big brown chair that had been in the family room on craigslist, along with a few other things. By the end of the day, we’d sold the chair and a sweet little desk/table.
The chair was given to me a few years back, so the $50 we sold it for was all profit. The table was a thrift store find; I sold it for a few dollars more than I originally paid. I didn’t really want to let it go–because I really like it–but I’m working hard on not holding onto things we don’t use. We just don’t have a place for it now. The guy who picked up looked so happy to have it. I’m glad it’s going to a place it will be loved.
To sum our craigslist lessons up…
We’ve realized these are the things we need to do to win the craigslist game in the future:
1. Look often–and maybe at off-times (see #4).
2. Try a variety of search terms. (You can find great tips for this from Kate at Retro Renovation.)
3. Use CraigsEasy to make searching faster.
4. Be first to reply. (I think we got lucky because Cane was looking in the late evening.)
5. Be willing to clean/refurbish.
And in case you’re wondering…
What about those Goodwill pillows you bought just last week, Rita?
(Because, of course you keep track of all my small purchases…) No worries–they’ll still be used. We turned our Ikea storage crate into a seating bench in the corner of the room, and the pillows make a nice back cushion. (We use the crate to store extra blankets and pillows for sleep-overs.)
Because the new chair is so much smaller than the brown beastie we sold, we had room to bring in an end table that we’d been storing in the garage.
Bringing it in and putting a lamp on it allows us to distribute lighting in a better way around the room, and it opens up some space around the storage cabinet. (Another future DIY project.)
Speaking of future DIY projects, this weekend I also scored this funky 70s ottoman for only $6! It doesn’t match yet, but one day it will!
Right now the room is pretty much a mishmash of stuff, but we’re OK with that.
It’s a bright, fun mix, and we like it much better than the dreary cave it was just two weeks ago.
Our next big move in here: Tear out the carpet!
It’s stained and gross, and it’s going bye-bye. (Sometimes, you can’t get rid of the dirt. We’ve tried with this carpet, and it’s a no-go.)
Right after we paint the exterior of the house and tile the bathroom.
We’ve got a lot in the works right now. We’re excited to share more with you later this week!
Speaking of sharing…
We’re hooking this post up to Her Library Adventures, The William Morris Project at Pancakes and French Fries, The Addicts (not so) Anonymous Link Party at Addicted 2 Decorating, and (because we think this definitely qualifies as a “green” project–and not just because of the sofa color), Sorta Crunchy‘s weekly Green Resource link up.
(Update July 1: Just discovered another thrifty sharing place: Simple Design’s Share Your Thrift Haul. Linking there, too.)
We’d love to hear about any of your craigslist adventures or efforts to make your home more beautiful or useful.


























Jun 24, 2012 @ 16:18:23
Wow! Awesome find
Thanks for sharing the CraigEasy search tool- so great!! I sell more than buy but it will make searches so much faster- thanks.
Jun 24, 2012 @ 16:58:33
OPD – I’ve bought and cleaned lots of furniture in my days of renting (about 15 years). It wasn’t until 2 years ago that I had an experience of OPD that has left a sour taste in my mouth for future purchases. We found the PERFECT microfiber forest green couch for our living room for $40. It was January. The couch sat in the garage while we worked on cleaning it. Other than the massive amounts of various types of dog hair, there was an indistinguishable smell that I just could not get rid of. We washed the covers 3 times using the vinegar/baking soda/detergent triage. Because it was microfiber, we brushed the fabric sofa frame with baking soda and vacuumed it up – over and over and over. We used a toothbrush with rubbing alcohol on the greasy looking spots that emerged after the dog hair was removed. In the end, we decided it must be the foam cushions holding onto the smell so I held out for a warmer day (March) and set them on racks in the driveway after soaking them with a vinegar solution and then the next day a thorough rinse. We brought the couch into the living room for 2 weeks and it seemed fine until I did the “Nestea Plunge” on it one day and the smell just poofed out at me like I hadn’t done an ounce of work. The smell was in the frame.
That was when we learned that sometimes other people’s dirt is VERY different from your dirt and there’s nothing saving it.
Jun 24, 2012 @ 18:41:05
Oh, that would be enough to put me off of used upholstery, too. And this reminds me of a piece of furniture with a smell I couldn’t get rid of, either. It was a cabinet with that musty, moldy smell–and it permeated anything I stored in it. I tried everything–charcoal, sun, bleach, etc.–and I finally had to concede defeat. Wish there was some way to know if smells really can’t be gotten rid of.
Jun 24, 2012 @ 19:04:36
that looks so retro cool, and goes great with the new paint color!
I buy a ton of stuff on CL, but I tend to stay away from upholstered stuff. In the NY area there is a real bedbug problem, so I never wanted to take the chance. (I bought one blue chair in fabulous shape from a bowling alley basement, but that’s it.) Plus my son has severe allergies, so I don’t even take wood stuff from a house with pets. (Obv we aren’t in the NY suburbs anymore, but I am still icked out by it.)
I find that shopping often and having patience is the key–I shopped for six months on a near daily basis for a campaign dresser before finding one.
Lisa recently posted..fancy movie theaters
Jun 25, 2012 @ 08:26:23
Hi Lisa–
I’ve never thought about bedbugs! That’s some OPD I definitely want no part of! I don’t hear much about them in our part of the world, but I know they’re around here, too.
And I guess part of winning on craigslist is having the kind of patience and persistence you mention. I usually don’t have enough of either.
Jun 24, 2012 @ 22:11:44
What a fabulous find! Love that shade of green. The whole room looks wonderful.
Jun 25, 2012 @ 08:23:45
Thanks, Alison! So glad you stopped by so I could discover your sweet blog. And I’ve been meaning to ask someone who blogs from Australia: Why are your second-hand stores called op shops? Hope you can enlighten me!
Jun 25, 2012 @ 22:00:33
op shop = opportunity shop. We are very good at shortening the name of just about anything over here!
Alison recently posted..Lovely linen
Jun 26, 2012 @ 08:11:36
I love the idea of “opportunity shop”! (This is the English teacher in me coming out…) Many of our thrift stores are non-profits that provide services for others with various kinds of needs–so the shopping we do there contributes to opportunities for others. And of course, there’s always an opportunity to find some kind of treasure for ourselves. I like op shop so much better than thrift store. I feel a new post coming on…
Jun 24, 2012 @ 23:30:28
The couches look fantastic with your new wall colour. And while the fabric may not be in excellent shape in a couple spots, the shape of them is divine. Oh and I love your embroidered owl.
Jun 25, 2012 @ 08:29:26
Hi Lori–Thanks for visiting. After hopping over to your blog, I can see why you like the owl! I wasn’t sure if he was cool or creepy, but at $3, I decided to bring him home on a trial basis. I’m kind falling in love with him. He was made with nice craftsmanship–the person who made him really took care with her work.
Jun 25, 2012 @ 06:44:27
What a great score Rita! The couch and chair look great in your room!

Kate recently posted..GETTING RID OF THE DIRTY DAYBED…
Jun 25, 2012 @ 08:30:46
Thanks, Kate. Still not as great as your Brasilia pieces, but I’m feeling encouraged to finally put one in the craigslist win column!
Jun 25, 2012 @ 10:18:41
I’ve had a few lucky finds…one a brand new Crate and Barrel teak headboard and king frame for 1/4th the retail price, and the other a huge free-at-curb metal chandelier that I turned into a backyard solar chandelier with solar lawn lights and colored LED solar lights. Love the vintage furniture finds you have…they sure dont’ make things like they used to.
Jun 25, 2012 @ 14:59:38
We’ve just discovered solar lawn lights–what a cool thing! I would never have thought of making a chandelier with them. Would love to see pics of that.
Jun 25, 2012 @ 12:20:14
Holy cow you do have a lot going on!!! SO glad to see tile going up. And I think the couches are the perfect touch of kitchy vintage. I love the almost monochromatic look of them … and such a steal!!
Karah @ thespacebetweenblog recently posted..the Haven lists of 3
Jun 25, 2012 @ 15:02:54
We found it really hard to get a lot done during the school year (when we’re both working), so I think we’re feeling like we have to maximize our time off. We’ve gone a little nutty, starting all kinds of projects at once. Today I had a spare hour, so I painted two of the entry walls, making the official count of in-progress projects…5. Holy cow is right.
Jun 25, 2012 @ 15:15:33
Hello,
I’ve been enjoying your blog for a few months now, and I really appreciate your “realness.” I was wondering if you minded a suggestion for your living room? Circles. you need some circular end tables and a circle or irregular shaped rug (ie cow hide)to break up your modern/clean lines. The couch in my living room is very similar to yours, but modern and plain green. And my chair is golden yellow retro wing back with an embroidery pattern of the same colour thru it. My room also needs some circular shapes and I am looking for some circular endtables, lamps and circles in artwork or mirrors to put up.
Thanks for sharing your home
Jun 26, 2012 @ 07:59:19
Hi Maria–I’m so glad you took the time to drop us a note. And we love suggestions, always. I especially love yours because I’ve been telling Cane for a while now that I think we need a round coffee table! Your note helped me realize that the shape is part of what we love about the rug in our living room (and that we maybe don’t need a round coffee table there) and that a round table in the family room would be perfect. I love an excuse to go thrifting/craigslisting! Thanks so much for your kind words and your great idea.
Jun 25, 2012 @ 15:21:27
I’m in love with a boy named Craig!
I also tipped my toe into the Craig’s List pond this weekend. We need to do our yearly shed clean up (we take everything out, sort, and restock.) It doesn’t take long but keeps things organized usually all summer long. I found a “Fluidity” exercise/ballet barre hiding in a dusty corner and decided to make that my first posting attempt. I had no idea how easy it was!
For me the hardest part was determining a fair price. They are currently selling on HSN.com for $240 and almost $500 on the Fluidity website. I went with the garage sale method of selling it for half retail. I listed it at $140 and was willing to go as low as $100.
Within 24 hours, I had four buyers!! Since this was my first time out, I didn’t know what to do next. I figured the first email I received was obviously the winner, so I responded to her then all the buyers and removed the post from my account on Craig’s List. Simple as that!
Maybe I should have priced it higher? Who knows, but what I do know is that by tomorrow I’ll be $140 richer, which happens to be exactly how much my grocery bill was for this week. Nice coincidence, don’t you think?!
I told my kids they better watch out for anything that isn’t nailed down. My camera has a USB port connector which makes downloading pictures to the Internet a snap! This could turn into a fun and lucrative hobby!!
Jun 26, 2012 @ 08:05:34
About time you lost your craigslist virginity, girl! (And for anyone who thinks this comment is really weird/inappropriate, I know Shannon from way back…)
The first time I sold on craigslist was last year, and I was amazed at how easy it was. When we moved, we sold quite a few pieces of furniture, which we used to buy a few pieces that fit the new house. It felt like free furniture.
As for pricing, what largely determines it for us is how much we want to get rid of the item. We tend to price low so the things move quickly and we don’t have any hassles about price. That said, I did try to sell a rocker last weekend and I know I priced it too high. No one inquired about it. It has sentimental value (rocked my babies in it), and I know that influenced the price I set. Still pondering what I really want to do with that…
Jun 25, 2012 @ 19:30:54
The room is coming along so nicely, Rita! And what a fun find. Whew, house projects are never ending, aren’t they!?
Hope you have a great week.
Keeping it Cozy recently posted..Peach Hand Pies
Jun 26, 2012 @ 08:15:12
Thanks, Andrea. Yes, never-ending! This room has a ways to go, but it’s getting there. Looking forward to seeing your daughter’s bedroom. I’m sure it’s beautiful (just like your kitchen)!
Jun 26, 2012 @ 09:46:15
Thanks, Rita! You inspired me to list a few items on CraigsList that I have been wanting to get out of my house. Good for you dealing with OPD – your room looks awesome!
Jun 29, 2012 @ 08:07:16
Thanks, Annie!
Jun 28, 2012 @ 07:56:40
Wow. Colourful and inviting. That is one great old couch! I love the lines–reminds me of those big old cars. Beautiful colour too. The room is looking fab.
I don’t know how long your tile project is taking, but ours lasted nearly three months–and it was our only bath tub and shower in the house. Crazy.
Jun 29, 2012 @ 08:09:08
We’ve been working (off and on) on our tile project since January. We’ve made major progress this week, though. Can’t wait to show it off, but we’re going to wait until it’s all the way done. So, 3 months sounds positively speedy to me!
Jun 28, 2012 @ 08:39:41
Rita, Your family room is looking amazing! What a change! I also love that pineapple vase thing…LOVE it. Did you read my response to your comment on the Woodsman Market post?
Alice Almighty recently posted..The William Morris Project, Week 25
Jun 29, 2012 @ 08:18:48
Hi Alice–No, I didn’t see your reply. I’ll send you an email…
Jun 28, 2012 @ 09:32:16
Rita,
I have never bought anything off Craig’s list! I want to….but where we live they never really sell anything on Craig’s List. But now you have inspired me!
blessings,
karianne
thistle recently posted..Blackberry Picking
Jun 29, 2012 @ 08:12:28
I guess we’re lucky to live near an area where Craigslist is big. But you have all those wonderful yard sales!
Jun 28, 2012 @ 10:32:40
I love the green in your new seating – and the shape, too! Here’s to hoping you encounter many more finds. I am definitely trying out Craigslist easy. I hate clicking on every single link!!! I’m so glad you shared about that.
The funnest part of this post for me, though, was that I scored the exact same funky 70′s ottoman as you did (also from Craigslist, but for $15) in an awesome green velvet. My little girls use it in their room in their reading corner. I love it :O)
Jun 29, 2012 @ 08:14:36
Oh, I would love that ottoman in green velvet (to go with the couch/chair). Would be worth the whole extra $9!
Jun 28, 2012 @ 22:49:38
Great find, and I’d never heard of CraigEasy. I also really like your tall lamp next to the chair. Pat yourselves on the back…great update so far.
kshire recently posted..Palm Springs: Girl’s Getaway
Jun 29, 2012 @ 08:17:13
Thanks for the encouragement! We’ve got a ways to go, but we’re happy with how it’s turning out so far.
Jun 29, 2012 @ 09:01:10
That fabric they are covered in wore forever and never seemed to age.
May recently posted..The Great Grimy Pan Clean-up
Jun 29, 2012 @ 12:24:37
Congrats on the lovely furniture! I just love a good deal.
You rock at mixing patterns–can’t wait to mix and match my own. Nice work!
Jun 30, 2012 @ 08:18:59
Really like the style and coloring of your new sofa and chair in that space — especially with the newly painted wall. Looks quite nice.
Unfortuately Craigslist isn’t very active here. But Freecycle definitely is. It’s been a Godsend for us. It’s amazing what people will take for free — and we’re not only thrilled that it’s gone, but also that it goes to a new home where the people are excited to have it. Several of the people have written us later to thank us profusely for the stuff they picked up – which has to equal some good karma points.
My mom is the best at finding CL deals. I’ll have to tell her about that CraigEasy thing though!